Mental Health in South Asian Communities

Mental health is just as important as physical health, but in many South Asian cultures, there is stigma surrounding mental illness. This can make it difficult for people to talk about their struggles and seek help.

Why does the stigma exist?

The stigma around mental health in South Asian communities stems from a variety of interconnected factors:

Mental health issues are rarely discussed openly within families and communities. This creates a strong sense of isolation and shame for those struggling. Feeling alone and judged then discourages individuals from reaching out for help, which only perpetuates and continues the cycle of silence.

Often in South Asian families, there is a lack of understanding about mental health conditions. This contributes to misconceptions that can be harmful. Some may view mental health challenges as a sign of weakness or personal failure. It’s quite common for families to say things like "just toughen up" or “it’s not a big deal”.

Others might dismiss mental health issues entirely and do not perceive them as being a real medical condition.

This attitude minimizes challenges that people face and discourages them from seeking help.

South Asian cultures tend to emphasize family honour, respect for elders, and place a strong emphasis on academic and professional achievement.

The pressure to conform to such high and unrealistic expectations can create immense stress and anxiety. Children feel obligated to prioritize their parents' desires over their own, which then leads to them neglecting their mental health needs.

The Role of Family and Community

In many South Asian families, there is also pressure to uphold the family's image. Since mental health issues are perceived as being shameful and are often a taboo topic, this often leads individuals to suppress their struggles to avoid making the family look bad. This prevents them from getting the help they need and can lead to feelings of isolation and hopelessness.

It is also quite common for a mental health diagnosis to be seen as a reflection on the entire family.

This perception can stem from the belief that mental illness is a result of poor upbringing or family dysfunction. Once again, fear of judgement or attempting to protect the family’s reputation becomes another barrier to accessing support.

This fear of judgement and shame can lead to social isolation, which are actually shown to worsen symptoms of depression and anxiety, creating a viscious cycle. Feeling alone reinforces the belief that these struggles are unique and shameful, further hindering them

from seeking help. Social isolation can be particularly harmful to mental health, as social connections provide a sense of belonging and support.

When individuals feel isolated due to the stigma surrounding mental illness, it can worsen their symptoms and make it even harder to reach out for help. This isolation causes anxiety, creating a vicious cycle that can be difficult to break without support.

Religion and Spirituality

Religion plays an important role in many South Asian cultures, and some believe that mental health issues can be addressed simply through faith and prayer. While faith can be a source of comfort and strength, it shouldn't be seen as a replacement for professional help.

Mental health conditions are often complex and may require therapeutic interventions from qualified professionals like doctors, therapists or psychiatrists.

These professionals can help people develop coping mechanisms, manage symptoms, and work towards recovery.

Media Portrayals and Gender Roles

The media often fails to portray mental health issues accurately. Portrayals in movies and television shows can create negative stereotypes and misconceptions.

These portrayals can be misleading and contribute to the stigma surrounding mental illness. For example, a movie might depict someone with depression as constantly withdrawn and emotionless, which doesn't accurately reflect the experiences of people with depression.

Additionally, traditional gender roles within South Asian cultures can place different expectations on men and women. These expectations can create a burden for women, who might face additional pressure to prioritize family needs, often neglecting their own well-being.

South Asian men on the other hand, are expected to stay strong, refrain from showing any emotion, which can make it difficult for them to seek help for mental health struggles.

This bottling up and suppression of emotions eventually gets worse and worse, increasing their vulnerability to stress, anxiety, and depression.

Intergenerational Trauma

The silence surrounding mental health in South Asian families can be further worsened by intergenerational trauma.

Historical events like displacement, or economic hardship can have deep impacts that are passed down through generations.

These unaddressed traumas can manifest as anxiety, depression, or difficulty expressing emotions.

However, due to the stigma and the lack of open communication, they go unaddressed. Parents who grew up in environments where mental health wasn't acknowledged may be less able to recognize their children's mental health needs.

Furthermore, immigrant families are often in “survival mode” to get basic necessities like food, shelter, and clothing. As a result, they do not have the time or space to address mental health at all.

This perpetuates the stigma and makes it even harder for younger generations to break free and seek help.

This silence is often rooted in conditioning, a learned behaviour passed down through generations. Imagine a child growing up in a household where emotions are rarely discussed, and struggles are hidden for fear of bringing shame to the family. This child internalizes the message that mental health issues are something to be suppressed. The child then perpetuates the stigma, making it even harder for future generations to speak up about their own struggles.

Colonial Impacts

Colonialism continues to shape mental health conversations in South Asian communities. Colonial powers often dismantled traditional healing practices and imposed Western medical systems that didn't fully consider or respect indigenous understandings of mental illness. This created a disconnect between traditional support structures and the Western healthcare system.

Furthermore, Western bias can exist within some mental health services, where a "one-size-fits-all" approach might not address the unique cultural nuances of mental health challenges in South Asian cultures. This disconnect can make it difficult for individuals to find culturally competent care and contribute to feeling disconnected from the mental health system itself.

Breaking the Cycle: What can we do?

Here's are some actionable steps to work towards eliminating the stigma:

Start conversations about mental health with friends and family.

Share your experiences and encourage others to do the same.

Normalize seeking help for mental health concerns just like you would for any other physical health issue.

Educate yourself and others about mental health conditions and available treatments. Many resources are available online, through community organizations, and at local libraries.

Speak out against negative stereotypes and misconceptions surrounding mental health. Help create a culture where seeking help is seen as a sign of strength and self-care.

Unaddressed trauma within families can be passed down through generations.

Recognizing and addressing these issues is essential for promoting mental well-being.

Sources:

Burr, J. (2002). Cultural stereotypes of women from South Asian communities: mental health care professionals’ explanations for patterns of suicide and depression. Social science & medicine, 55(5), 835-845.

Chaudhry, T., & Chen, S. H. (2019). Mental illness stigmas in South Asian Americans: A cross-cultural investigation. Asian American Journal of Psychology, 10(2), 154.

Huang, L., Hiscock, H., & Dalziel, K. M. (2019). Parents’ perception of children’s mental health: seeing the signs but not the problems. Archives of disease in childhood, 104(11), 1102-1104.

Loya, F., Reddy, R., & Hinshaw, S. P. (2010). Mental illness stigma as a mediator of differences in Caucasian and South Asian college students' attitudes toward psychological counselling. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 57(4), 484.

Millner, U. C., Maru, M., Ismail, A., & Chakrabarti, U. (2021). Decolonizing mental health practice: Reconstructing an Asian-centric framework through a social justice lens. Asian American Journal of Psychology, 12(4), 333.

Karasz, A., Gany, F., Escobar, J., Flores, C., Prasad, L., Inman, A., ... & Diwan, S. (2019). Mental health and stress among South Asians. Journal of immigrant and minority health, 21, 7-14.

Shaligram, D., Khan, M., Adiba, A., & Anam, S. (2022). Cultural considerations for working with South Asian Youth. Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Clinics, 31(4), 789-803.